I don’t like target=_blank

target=_blank makes links open in a new browser window. I don’t like it, because I don’t need it.
Reasons against open links in new windows

  • Everybody can open links in a new window (if you are still using Internet Explorer with all of its disabilities) or in new Tabs (when you are using a good browser) by holding Shift or Ctrl when clicking on a hyperlink.
  • The choice of whether a link will open in a new window should be the end user’s choice, not the web designer’s choice..
  • It breaks the Back-Button.
  • New windows in Win XP open always on the top, so you will loose the “main site”.
  • It breaks the website structure if internal links open in new windows.

Reasons for open links in new windows

  • Users are quite confirm with the “multi-window” environment.
  • It’s easier to close a window then it is to find the Back-Button.
  • Most people don’t know that they can easily open links in new windows by holding Shift or Ctrl when clicking on a hyperlink.
  • For webmasters: Don’t make your visitors think *g*

We deactivated the target=_blank attribute for internal links in the past for some days and got tons of negative feedback. So now I want to know, how the links to the wallpaper download sites in the new Skins.be should behave. Would it be an opportunity if we offer a checkbox that makes links to the wallpapers eopn in new windows (but opens in the same window by default)?

This entry was posted on Friday, April 7th, 2006 at 12:13 pm and is filed under Main Page. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

12 Responses to “I don’t like target=_blank”

  1. kouilloman Says:

    use a browser with mitre…
    so you will have all the pages in the same window…

  2. Sunkan Says:

    I think you could add it as an option for member so you can activate it if they think it is needad.
    I like it off because it is my chois to open it in a new window or not.

  3. Robert Says:

    I don’t really mind. I keep all internal links to the same window while externals to a new one simply from habit.

  4. kees Says:

    i think you should give us the option. So we can choose what we prefer.

    Personally i like it in the same window, as i can go easily back with the back button on my logitech mouse 🙂

  5. Lee Says:

    i think it would be better to keep the target=_blank for visitors and to make an option for members so that they can choose what they do prefer.

  6. Ricky Says:

    I really prefer the wallpapers to open in new windows. it is easier for me to find an close as i usually download the wallpaper and then close that window and so on. if i dont want it to open in a new window then i just copy the link, make a new tab and pase the url or whatever.

    new windows are just common and comfortable for most people. it’s the norm. well for me anyway. it’s no big inconvenience if a link opens in a new window really.

  7. G Says:

    “if i dont want it to open in a new window then i just copy the link, make a new tab and pase the url or whatever.”

    This is real inteligence… almost George Bush’s level. Congratulations.

  8. Chaz Says:

    Keep the wallpapers opening in new windows automatically. It is really annoying to have to go back and forth between individua wallpapers and the “gallery” area.

  9. Nate Says:

    I really like the way the pages open now in a seprate window. Cause then I can open sevral of them at a time and let them load on my slow intrenet connection. But I also do agree that you should let members have an option to be able to do it either way. That would make the most sens. I would keep the site with the pictures opening in a different page for vistors.

  10. Mike Says:

    I’d take the “it’s the user’s choice” direction and remove target=_blank. It really bugs me when I click a simple link (anywhere, not just here) and get a whole new FF window. (Although now I middle-click all wallpapers out of habit [to get a new tab] so I wouldn’t notice a change in the target.)

  11. pup Says:

    New windows are the devil. Rosie will visit your house and try to have you impregnate her and will not leave until her mission is complete.

    Seriously.

    People stop using IE6.

    New windows suck for ANY browser. Get Firefox or Opera or something with tabs. Hit CTRL then click on the link. Ding, new tab. Until a “target=_newtab” comes around, this is the BEST WAY, not to mention the ONLY WAY to browse.

  12. sam Says:

    People will moan if you change it either way, they get thier habits and are resistant to change.

    I think that useablilty should dictate how you handle links. I’ve never liked new windows spawning without asking me. It’s takes my control and choice about the matter away. If I want a link in a new window then it’s trivial for me to make that happen. If I don’t, then the default behaviour should be in the same window. New windows from links are like popups and who wants tham?

    Newbies to the net are always phased by links opening in new windows. It’s non-intuitive and because of the association with popups and agressive advertising can be a real turn of.

    Give the user the choice. If memebers want the old style, give them the option in tier settings.

Leave a Reply

Welcome to the world of celebrities, models & sexy Girls at blog.skins.be is proudly powered by WordPress
Entries (RSS) and Comments (RSS).



Related Posts with Thumbnails